For example, the quran states that one night, allah took muhammad to alaqsa mosque in jerusalem. Contradictions weak points in the quran there is a religious islamic troll that i am currently arguing with, while maintaining sanity of course. Islam came in africa peacefully while christianity was imposed on africans by the white colonists who colonized africa, there is no a single contradiction in the quran, while there are numerous and uncountable contradictions in the manmade bible. Contradictions in the quran answering christianity what. A version of this page is also available in the following languages. We shall study in this chapter the contradictions between the quran, the basic and unique source of islam, and the fabricated hadiths. Answering islam, a christianmuslim dialog and apologetic. Christianity, islam, answering christianity, answering islam, islam, allah, muhammad, jesus, christianity, christ, quran, quran, koran. Errors, contradictions, and quran page 4 christianity. A topical study of the quran is a helpful starting point to get an overview on its major topics. When we look at the word contradiction, lets gain an understanding of it before moving forward.
He made it firmly anchored mountains above it and blessed it and decreed that it contain the amount of food it provides, all in four days, equally for those asking for those who ask. The criticisms of the translation and commentary of the holy quran, made by. Mistakes in the quran which prove islam is false part i. When asking this question, you should consider the context of the quran. A guide to quranic contradictions by abul kasem, april 20, 2008. Contradictions between muslim traditions and the quran other web web sites with pages on errors, contradictions or problems in the quran.
Answering contradictions in quran answering muhammad s. If the quran is a perfect book from allah, then there shouldnt be any contradictions in it. The internal contradiction in the quran is too obvious that it is not from gabriel nor from allah sura 4. There are many reasons of much more substantial nature why we do not believe the quran to be from the one true god.
For the muslim, the seemingly contradictory actions of god are not problematic. Contradictions in the quraan 2 created the earth in two days, and set up others like him. When we observe the fatal consequences of the adoption of the hadiths as a source of religion, we shall see better the importance of going back to the quran. Zakir naik on bible contradictions the following is a list of biblical contradictions that were used by dr. Readers may access this list at here is a reply to each item of katzs list. Look, my whole point of this is that i am tired of hearing how every other religious book out there is wrong and has lies but the quran is perfect i see that no one stepped up to defend some of the other things that i postedlike this these arent errors, ill get back to those in a minute. The quran states that it is a perfect book preserved on tablets in heaven surah 85. Apr 23, 2012 quran, which was the original reference for the quran, as recited by muhammad, that quran was destroyed and mutilated by marawan ibn alhakam and he demolished it completely those historical events were mentioned in the following references. Plenty of evidence shows that the early muslims understood the verse in this straightforward way. Zakir naik on bible contradictions answering islam. Then after that the sons of adam became numerous, and they were created from water, meaning the mans semen which contains the sperm that fertilizes the womans egg. Logical consistency no contradictions within the quran.
Contradictions in the quran answering christianity. Contradictions and errors a hub page that leads to other articles related to contradictions and errors. Already hast thou received some account of those apostles. So when the question comes up did allah have a son.
Answering islams critics is shabir allys new page in response to the quran contradictions. Now let us have a closer look at this specific story. Textual integrity todays text is exactly the same as recited by muhammad. This list, much like my list of bible contradictions, is evergrowing. Introduction the quran, with its many ambiguous statements, is an ideal scripture to find contradictions. Refutation of the socalled contradictions in the quran. The new testament confirms the apocalypse revelation in greek of peter which claims that jesus never died on the cross. This verse is further amplified by the already quoted texts. The authors, a christian apologist and a former muslim, provide apologetic answers to prepare christians for ministry in the islamic context. However, the quran is not an easy book to understand. They will grow on its banks, as a seed carried by the torrent grows. Answering islam s critics is shabir allys new page in response to the quran contradictions. Some of the errors in the quran are selfcontradictions that naskh tries to bridge. Contradictions by nameby bookin the biblein the book of mormonsaq db forum.
This testimony about god given in the quran doesnt inspire much confidence in this god and his revelations. Had it been from anyone besides allah, there would have been many contradictions. I come from an islamic country but currently i live in a western country. Contradictions in the quran the purpose of this page we do not reject the quran because of this list of contradictions. Verses contradicting each other or the laws of logic external errors2. The answers are based mainly on tafseer books and basic logic. Samples of quranic contradictions, inconsistencies and errors. My reasons why i quit islam forever i was born in a devout muslim family belonging to sunni sect of islam. That is, we all deserve punishment simply for being human, until such a time as we. Indeed, those who believed and those who were jews or christians or sabeans before prophet muhammad those among them who believed in allah and the last day and did righteousness will have their reward with their lord, and no fear will ther. Answering islam 0115 are there contradictions in the quran. In this article, however, we would like to describe a quite different kind of weakness of the quran which we will refer to as a lack of theological professionalism.
No change can there be in the words of allah sura 10. Verses contradicting the earlier revelations further. Contrary to the muslim claim that the koran is perfect and free from contradiction, the koran is not only a bundle of contradictions, but a volume of confusion. Again, we must ask why an allknowing being would use such. Contradictions in the quran sinandcompositescriptures. The muslim claims about the quran concentrate around the topics of textual integrity todays text is exactly the same as recited by muhammad logical consistency no contradictions within the quran.
As for the claim that the quran is scientifically wrong, i also suggest you read what jochen has referenced. After all, how do i know that at any time, he isnt currently deceiving me. Detailed rebuttals to the so called errors in the noble quran. There is a huge difference in meaning between these two phrases which jochen uses. Of course, the muslims will deny any contradictions exist in the quran, but they do. The quran is the muslims holy book and it contains a wide variety of topics.
The book is written for all christians, whether you just want an introduction to islam, or want ideas for christianmuslim dialogue. And no question do they bring to you but we reveal to you the truth and the best explanation quran 25. Contradictions within the quran do they not consider the quran. Answering islams complete list of the socalled contradictions in the noble quran had. Quran contradictions occur when two or more verses, approached from a literalist perspective, state two or more things that cannot simultaneously be true. Moreover, the quran contains many contradictions and mistakes, both in terms of modern physical and medical knowledge and in terms of its references to biblical characters and events, e. There is a great website that deals with refuting contradictions in the quran, i suggest you visit if you are ever in doubt. The purpose of this site is to mention that there are no contradictions in quran. Muslims claim the quran is infallible and errorfree, while others claim the quran has errors. But the quran also has archaeological errors, historical errors, errors in logic and even elementary mathematics. I like christians,i appreciate their politeness,and you will never find me harsh regarding them,and so the post is also for defending islam,never to accuse christanity.
Some of the contradictions mentioned below might have already appeared on other web sites with slight variations. Contradictions in the quran answering christianity what is. The woman and the man guilty of adultery or fornication, flog them each with a hundred stripes. Christians believe that jesus christ was the son of god allah. Avoid copying the mushaf and recitation of this man. Some of the contradictions below could be debated, but some of them are clearly contradictions. Posts about quran contradictions written by rayan zehn. And is there a contradiction in the noble quran regarding idol gods not being able to create and jesus christ.
Contradictions in the quran answering islam home page. It will thus be within the reach of a greater number of people, so that benefiting by it they may acquire the understanding of the teachings of the holy quran. Quran contradictions are internal errors errors in relating the quran to itself, not external errors. Contradictions in the new testament that have no good answer. The quran is by definition replete with contradictions because of the hermeneutical doctrine of abrogation nasikh wa mansukh which basically means that allah gave a revelation to the prophet at one time and then later retracted that revelatio. Responses to all of the socalled errors in the noble quran. Jan 31, 2009 perhaps you feel that way because it is ingrained in muslims from the time they go to school or even before then that the quran is perfect. Read morecontradictions in the quran answering christianity. Mar 20, 20 the quran s claim that the buildings carved out of rock were made by the thamud during the time of salih is false they were also tombs, not houses as muhammad and the author of the quran evidently believed the quran, in 7. Contradictions in the quran more contradictions in the quran, answering islam.
Answers to contradictions in the quran muslim answers. Contradictions difficulties in the quran answering islam. A strength of the book is that, for the first half, it does not require you to remember lots of details about islam but instead shows how the bible and christian doctrine speak to islam. Keep the musahif that are with you, and conceal them. This means that when there is a contradiction in the quran, the later verses cancel out.
Answering has the new testament been corrupted answering the quran says bible is not corrupt answering more questions for muslims. Contradictions in the quraan answering christianity. A christian missionary website contains a list of what are claimed to be internal contradictions in the quran. The errors in the quran disqualify the quran as the word of god, who is perfect and does not make errors. So this verse is also saying, that people with knowledge will know that the quran is from god even the unspecific verses and that people of understanding can truly grasp the meaning of the unspecific verses. Other web web sites with pages on errors, contradictions or problems in the quran. Refuting contradictions in quran questions and answers. By a new convert to islam the answer to answering islam on bible contradictions. Contradictions by nameby book in the bible in the book of mormonsaq db forum. Contact us if you have any comments or suggestions by clicking here. It abounds in repetitions and contradictions, which are not removed by the convenient. At the same time, its ambiguity provides a good opportunity for muslims to find some explanation or the other to negate a contradiction.
Contradictions between muslim traditions and the quran. There are many more questions and issues to be discussed, about history, archeology, authenticity, textual integrity, interpretation of passages, etc. But what do people do to come to this conclusion, is reading out of context etc. Every thing is created to worship god and to serve him in. The most sensitive issue with the quran concerns errors. This page is only about the topic of errors and contradictions in the bible. This section is devoted to exposing the false claims of contradiction in the quran, as has been circulated on various antiquranic sites. Verses contradicting the facts of history or science 3. Having just written a response to only the first entry above, he already claims they are all invalid. That is, we all deserve punishment simply for being human, until such a time as we are saved, if we ever are. In the last contradiction we were already looking at idol worship and the golden calf was mentioned in sura 4. Muhammad taught that there is one god, no trinity, jesus was not crucified, and that good works are needed for salvation. Islam, much like christianity and the torah, is not immune from contradicting itself.
It can be shown throughout the research that the bulk of the accusations are a product of either poor understanding of the quranic words and verses, or on the reliance on. During my university study, one of my subjects was islamic studies. Had it been from other than allah, they would surely have found therein much discrepancies. We will allude to each specific contradiction and proceed to give our response. Yusuf alis translation renders take reminderadmonition correction to be grasp the message. The list contains fortynine numbered items authored by jochen katz. Answering contradictions in quran christian apologetics. Tafseer books are books that were written by scholars of islam to explain the meanings of the verses of the quran. Firstly, quran says it is for confirming the earlier revelations in the torah and the gospel but did not say it is replacing nor correcting the gospel. Sahih albokhary, the conquest chapter, converse number 4000. There are already many articles available on wikiislam about contradictions and errors in the quran concerning logic, history, mathematics, cosmology and many more subjects. Dec 04, 2008 list of 70 discrepancies of both internal and external contradictions in quran.
When i accepted islam he was but in the loins of a disbelieving manmeaning zaid bin thabitand it was regarding this that abdullah bin masud said. Muslims are convinced that the quran is free from error, but you wont believe how easy it is to find contradictions in it. But that leaves open the question, could allah have a son. What if a muslim kills muslim in the name of allah apart from nonmuslims. Islam follows from both judaism and christianity, building upon them, absorbing jesus into the quran, but not his divinity. If heaven and earth are eternal according to islam, these verses imply that the.
Islamic responses to answering islams and all of the other antiislamic sites. I have seen some of the websites too and have looked in my own copy of the quran to make sure the passages are correct and there are numerous contradictions. Islam is one of the worlds fasted growing religions. The primary source of the missionaries argument is here before we deal with the socalled contradictions in the quran, especially the internal contradictions, it is important to determine the correct methodology for the understanding of the quran. In any case we christians see in this whole subject just a theological gimmick to explain contradictions.
Oct 28, 2017 muslims are convinced that the quran is free from error, but you wont believe how easy it is to find contradictions in it. No change can there be in the words of allah and there is none that can alter the words of allah. There are three basic categories of contradictions in the quran. Replies to the claims of contradictions in the quran. Below is a list of several authoritative verses in the quran and the hadith that are contradictory. The quran is viewed to be the scriptural foundation of islam and is believed by muslims to have. A viewers asks people say quran has contradictions, i know it doesnt.
Muslims believe that allah revealed a book to each of abraham, moses, david and jesus. The quran an evaluation of the muslim claims before criticizing any book, one should read it and get to know it. Its all done in the name of allah, quran and islam. But quran also has historical and archaeological errors, as well as errors in mathematics and logic. The purpose of this site the purpose of this site is to mention that there are no contradictions in quran. Anyone of you can check it that nothing about the descent of prophet adam a. But, is it a religion of peace, violence, or a little of both. Regarding islam the quran says in surah nisa, chapter 4, verse no. The purpose of this site is to mention that quran is the book of allah the site is in response to the 101 contradictions in quran. Many of the errors in the quran are self contradictions that naskh tries to cover up. The quran, with its many ambiguous statements, is an ideal scripture to find contradictions. The following are a list of the issues raised and their answers.
114 1491 486 556 663 501 785 797 577 161 396 231 930 1130 1035 1235 76 402 55 462 456 1351 1038 528 782 942 590 556 940 1126 1333 501 403 717 1299 381 901 182 306 1229